top of page

Shepard Insurance Agency

Make a Payment

Find your insurance company’s payment phone number and website link here.

Personal Lines

American Modern

(800) 543-2644

Arrowhead (Palomar Earthquake)

(877) 233-9722

Foremost

(800) 532-4221

GeoVera

(800) 324-6020

Hartford

Pay by Phone: AUTO

(800) 624-5578

Pay by Phone: HOME

(877) 896-9320

Hartford AARP

Pay by Phone: AUTO

(800) 423-0567

Pay by Phone: HOME

(800) 423-6789

Mercury

(800) 503-3724

Orion

(800) 697-6117

Pacific Specialty

(800) 303-5000

PersonalUmbrella.com (Markel)

Progressive

(800) 776-4737

Safeco

(800) 332-3226

Travelers

(888) 564-5043

Commercial Lines

Hartford

(866) 467-8730

Liberty Mutual

(877) 688-8254

Mercury

(800) 503-3724

Progressive

(800) 444-4487

State Compensation Insurance Fund

(888) 782-8338

Travelers

(877) 307-4202

bottom of page